BEYOND CESAR MILLAN
  • Home
  • Riley video comments
  • Shadow video comments
  • Paul Owens - Dog Whisperer
  • IAABC (behaviorists)
  • AnimalBehaviorAssociates.com
  • AHA (American Humane Assoc)
  • ACVB (behaviorists)
  • APBC (UK)
  • AVSAB (vets)
  • AVSAB leaflet
  • AVSAB 2
  • Alexandra Semyonova
  • Andrew Luescher
  • Barry Eaton
  • Bristol University
  • Darlene Arden
  • Janet Farricelli CPDT-KA
  • Jolanta Benal
  • Jo Jacques
  • Janis Bradley
  • Jean Donaldson
  • Kathy Meyer
  • Joyce Kesling
  • Kathy Sdao
  • Kendal Shepherd
  • LA Times comments board
  • Lee Charles Kelley
  • Lisa Laney
  • Marina Kviker
  • Mary Harwelik
  • Nancy Freedman-Smith
  • New York Times
  • Dr Nicholas Dodman
  • Nicole Wilde
  • Dr Patricia Khuly
  • San Francisco Chronicle
  • Scienceline
  • Dr Sophia Yin
  • Steve Dale
  • Dr Suzanne Hetts
  • Talented Dog Blog
  • University of Pennsylvania
  • Vyolet Michaels
  • Owners & trainers 1
  • Owners & trainers 2
  • Owners & trainers 3
  • Owners & trainers 4
  • Owners & trainers 5
  • Owners & trainers 6
  • Dogtime.com
  • eHow.com
  • Facebook
  • Book reviews
  • To those who defend CM
  • Shadow and Riley ~ Tiffany Allen
  • Amazon reviews
  • KomoNews video
  • Youtube reviews
  • PDXDog.com
  • Modern Dog mag readers
  • Happiest Dog Blog
  • Dogs In Danger
  • voice4dogs
  • Site feedback
  • Add your comment or contact me

By Dr Sophia Yin

Virtually everyone who started as a dog trainer over 15-20 years ago started out using traditional dog training techniques:  similar to those used by Cesar Millan (National Geographic’s The Dog Whisperer). This is how most dogs were trained back then. As a result we have first hand experience as to why and when such punishment-based techniques might work, the pitfalls, and why and when other techniques work better.

Traditional training techniques are based on the idea that we must become the dominant leader and rule our pets the way a wolf would rule a pack. That is, they assume most misbehavior in dogs is due to the dog is trying to be dominant and then they employ techniques that they think a wolf (since dogs are seen as having a social structure similar to wolves) would perform in a wolf pack. In order to evaluate whether this reasoning is valid, we must first understand what dominance is. 

Read the rest of Dr Yin's essay here:

http://askdryin.com/dominance.php
Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.