BEYOND CESAR MILLAN
  • Home
  • Riley video comments
  • Shadow video comments
  • Paul Owens - Dog Whisperer
  • IAABC (behaviorists)
  • AnimalBehaviorAssociates.com
  • AHA (American Humane Assoc)
  • ACVB (behaviorists)
  • APBC (UK)
  • AVSAB (vets)
  • AVSAB leaflet
  • AVSAB 2
  • Alexandra Semyonova
  • Andrew Luescher
  • Barry Eaton
  • Bristol University
  • Darlene Arden
  • Janet Farricelli CPDT-KA
  • Jolanta Benal
  • Jo Jacques
  • Janis Bradley
  • Jean Donaldson
  • Kathy Meyer
  • Joyce Kesling
  • Kathy Sdao
  • Kendal Shepherd
  • LA Times comments board
  • Lee Charles Kelley
  • Lisa Laney
  • Marina Kviker
  • Mary Harwelik
  • Nancy Freedman-Smith
  • New York Times
  • Dr Nicholas Dodman
  • Nicole Wilde
  • Dr Patricia Khuly
  • San Francisco Chronicle
  • Scienceline
  • Dr Sophia Yin
  • Steve Dale
  • Dr Suzanne Hetts
  • Talented Dog Blog
  • University of Pennsylvania
  • Vyolet Michaels
  • Owners & trainers 1
  • Owners & trainers 2
  • Owners & trainers 3
  • Owners & trainers 4
  • Owners & trainers 5
  • Owners & trainers 6
  • Dogtime.com
  • eHow.com
  • Facebook
  • Book reviews
  • To those who defend CM
  • Shadow and Riley ~ Tiffany Allen
  • Amazon reviews
  • KomoNews video
  • Youtube reviews
  • PDXDog.com
  • Modern Dog mag readers
  • Happiest Dog Blog
  • Dogs In Danger
  • voice4dogs
  • Site feedback
  • Add your comment or contact me

The trouble with Cesar

By Leslie (no surname given)

While television star Cesar Millan (who turned down our request for an interview) is credited with placing dog training on the public radar, the field's most respected behaviorists and trainers are concerned that many of Millan's ideas are unfounded. As for his methods? A few are downright harmful.

Putting your dog in his place Cesar's way: Dogs assume either a dominant or submissive role in their "pack." If he doesn't get off the couch when you ask him to, it's your dog's way of telling you that he's dominant and you're submissive.

Why he's way off: The notion of a rigid pack hierarchy with fixed roles between humans and dogs is largely a myth. Dogs are most likely to do what we humans ask when they clearly understand what we want - not as a sign of submission. Patricia McConnell explains: "So many issues - sitting on the couch, coming when called - have nothing to do with social status, any more than how you do on a math exam reflects your social status. A dog who doesn't sit when you ask him to sit - in most cases - simply doesn't understand what you want."

The truth: In groups of canines, roles among individual members are both fluid and give-and-take.

Treating fear with fear Cesar's way: You can "cure" a dog's fear by overwhelming him with the very stimulus that terrifies him.

Why he's way off: Imagine treating a human's acrophobia by dangling him over the edge of a skyscraper. This technique, called "flooding," actually leads to further psychological trauma in the form of learned helplessness: An animal learns that resistance is futile - his spirit is broken and he ceases to assert himself.

Trish King, Director of the Animal Behavior & Training Department at the Marin Humane Society observes: "In some of his shows, Cesar tells the owner how 'calm and submissive' a dog is, when to me, the dog looks shut down and fearful."

The truth: It may take weeks or months for your dog to truly overcome deep-rooted fear - and setbacks along the way are to be expected.

Snapping the leash or rolling the dog Cesar's way: Physical corrections - such as snapping a dog's leash or forcefully rolling him onto his back - are an effective way to garner good behavior.

Why he's way off: Physical corrections add to your dog's stress rather than offer instructive information. You may temporarily stun your dog into obedience in the short run, but in the long run, the use of physical force increases aggression and, ultimately, your behavioral problems.

"You can lead with force, like Saddam Hussein, or you can be a benevolent leader to your dog by choosing a style more like Gandhi's," says Tamar Geller, trainer to Oprah Winfrey's dogs and author of The Loved Dog. "Your approach will determine the type of relationship you have - and whether your dog acts out of intimidation... or respect."

The truth: Rewarding for the behavior you do want, as opposed to punishing for any number of behaviors you don't want, clearly communicates to your dog what's expected and is far more likely to generate confident, appropriate behavior.

http://knol.google.com/k/leslie/the-dog-trainers-trainer/Z9llszjv/pwgNsw?domain=knol.google.com&locale=en#

also posted at

www.dogtime.com/cesar-millan-and-ian-dunbar.html
--------------------------------
Comments

At last someone who thinks the exact same as me about Ceser Millan!!!!!!
I just can not understand why people think so highly of this man when all he does is cause more stress and upset for the dog......leading to very repressed dogs!

Anon.


Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.